REAL PISTOL CALIBER CARBINES HAVE LEVERS

by JT, Saturday, April 02, 2022, 09:54 (902 days ago) @ JimT

Real Pistol Caliber Carbines Have Levers!
By John Taffin
Much attention has been given recently to pistol caliber carbines, especially ARs chambered in 9 mm. So much attention, in fact, some might think it’s a new idea. Not quite. Carbines chambered in pistol length cartridges go back well over 160 years.
The very first attempts, some more successful than others, to come up with a repeating firearm involved pistol length cartridges. The first successful repeater, the Model 1860 Henry, was chambered in the .44 Rimfire which is definitely a cartridge which proved to be suitable for chambering in sixguns. The Spencer arrived about the same time as the Model 1860 Henry and it also featured a pistol length cartridge. The Model 1860 Henry was improved to the Model 1866 Winchester and was still chambered in the same .44 Rimfire. In late 1869 Smith & Wesson came forth with the first successful big bore cartridge firing revolver chambered in the .44 S&W American, a centerfire cartridge, however it was also chambered in the .44 Rimfire.
1873 saw the arrival of the first Center-Fire Winchester with the Model of 1873 chambered in .44 Winchester Centerfire (.44 WCF) or as it is most commonly called today, the .44-40. Meanwhile, the same year Colt issued their Single Action Army in .45 Colt. Prior to this Colt Cartridge Conversions were available in .44 Colt and many believe the first Single Action Army was actually chambered in .44 Rimfire.
I recently read, in another magazine, that the Winchester 1873 was chambered in vintage revolver rounds. Actually that is backwards! Winchester went on to chamber the 1873 in a necked down .44-40, the .38 WCF followed by a small bore cartridge, the .32 WCF. These are more commonly known today as the .38-40 and .32-20. They were originally rifle cartridges. Colt chambered their Single Action Army in all three of the Winchester Centerfire cartridges, however they all arrived first in lever action carbines. Winchester also necked down the .32-20 to come up with the .25-20, however Colt did not chamber their Single Action Army in this dandy little cartridge. It remained for custom sixgunsmiths today to accomplish this.
At the time, Winchester did not chamber their lever action Model 1873 in .45 Colt with a couple reasons which seem obvious. One problem would be feeding. The .45 Colt is a straight-wall cartridge, while the .44-40, .38-40, and .32-20 are all bottled-neck cartridges, or tapered if you will, making them much easier to feed from the action into the chamber. Another reason, probably the most important, is found by looking at the rims of. .45 Colt cartridges. The original rim was very small without much area for an extractor to grab onto. And I recall reading of handloaders complaining in the 1940s-50s of rims pulling off when cases were re-sized giving birth to the myth of weak .45 Colt brass. Even today, the .45 Colt cartridge which has a larger diameter case than the .44 Magnum, actually has the same size rim. An improvement in modern brass is the channel cut around the base of the cartridge case right in front of the rim which allows a better grasp by the ejector. Even so I don’t believe any lever action carbines were chambered in .45 Colt until quite a while after both Marlin and Winchester chamber the .44 Magnum which was in the mid-to late 60s.
One of the great attributes of the 1860s/1866/1873 Winchesters were how smoothly they operated. They are very particular about overall case length, however with the right ammunition it is almost a spiritual experience working the lever of one of these great guns. Today’s replicas work exactly the same way. These first leverguns could easily be operated without removing the butt from the shoulder and this is true of most leverguns today. Keep the butt on the shoulder and work the action with authority.
After the 1873 Winchester the Models 1876 and 1886 arrived chambered in what we normally think of as rifle cartridges, such as the .45-60 and .45-70. Then in 1892 Winchester went back to their pistol length roots modernizing the 1873 Winchester into what is basically a miniaturized Model 1886 but chambered in the same cartridges as the Model 1873 Winchester. The Model 1892 proved to be one of the slickest handling and strongest lever action carbines of all time.
Although Real Pistol Caliber Carbines are lever actions we do see the beginnings of handy carbines with the arrival of the .351 Winchester Self Loading (WSL) in the semi-automatic model of 1907. In 1941 the United States military adopted the .30 M1 Carbine which was widely used in WWII. Ruger still chambers their Blackhawk revolver in .30 Carbine. The real modern era of PCCs lever action-style began in the early 1950s. Ward Koozer, a gunsmith in Arizona, began converting .32-20 Winchester Model 1892s to .357 Magnum. One of my favorite articles found in this magazine at the time was by Kent Bellah and featured his sixgun/levergun combination consisting of a 3-1/2” Smith & Wesson .357 Magnum and a Koozer converted Model 1892.
I believe the first Magnum Pistol Caliber Carbines lever action-style factory produced were the Winchester 1894 and the Marlin 336 both chambered in .44 Magnum in the late 1960s. In 1969, the old Marlin 1894 was resurrected and offered in .44 Magnum, and then later in .44-40. This action, being shorter, is better suited to sixgun cartridges than the .30-30 length 336 action. Marlin also made a special run of Trapper-style 1894 carbines in .44 Magnum and .45 Colt with a 16 -1/4" barrel, full magazine tube that holds seven or eight rounds depending upon the nose length of the bullet, a recoil pad on its straight gripped stock, checkering on forearm and buttstock , and excellent sights. Winchester would also go on to chamber their Model 1894 in .45 Colt and .357 Magnum offering both in Trapper versions. In the 1970s, Marlin brought forth their Model 1894C chambered in .357 Magnum. This is one of the handiest carbines ever offered and our family has four of them currently in use. Marlin also chambered this little carbine in .32 Magnum, .32-20, and .25-20 and since they did not come up with one in .327 Magnum I had my local ‘smith convert one of the .32 Magnums to this longer cartridge.
One of the great benefits of Cowboy Action Shooting is the resurrection of so many classic Winchesters all chambered in pistol-length cartridges by Uberti. All three of the original Winchesters, Models 1860, 1866, and 1873 have been offered in the original three chamberings as well as .45 Colt, .357 Magnum, and now the Model 1873 is even available in .44 Magnum. The .38 Special can also be found and two of my favorite easy shooting PCCs are the replica Model 1866 chambered in .38 Special as well as a very rare .44 Special.
In the period between the two World Wars El Tigre 1892 .44-40 carbines were produced under a license from Winchester in South America. In the 1950s these could be purchased for $39.95, however I waited 50 years too long and had to pay more than 20 times this much to get an excellent example. The bonus is it outshoots my original Winchester 1892. In the 1980s, I believe, the first examples of the excellent Rossi replicas of the Model 1892 began arriving. These have been offered in .44-40, .44 Magnum, .45 Colt, and .357 Magnum. I recently purchased a stainless steel version of the latter, had the barrel cut back to 16-1/4”, added a Lyman Model 66A receiver sight, and had the stock refinished to make it a weather-beating match to the stainless steel finish. This could easily be the Perfect PCC.
About the same time Rossi was bringing forth their replica 1892s, Browning also offered the Model B92 chambered in .357 Magnum and .44 Magnum. These are beautifully fitted and finished PCCs and worth looking for on the used gun market. Uberti has also offered a long line up of Replica Model 1892s in several barrel lengths, including those with octagon barrels, and chamberings such as .45 Colt and .44 Magnum. Winchester also now offers their Miroku-produced Model 1892 in most chamberings at various times including .38-40. These are also beautifully fitted and finished, perhaps even better examples that the originals.
Currently Henry Repeating Arms also offers PCCs chambered in .357 Magnum, .44 Magnum, and is the only manufacturer to offer a .327 Magnum version. I recently purchased three lever action .357 Magnum carbines from three different manufacturers. Two of them had very heavy trigger pulls of 7-1/2 to 8 pounds as well as somewhat gritty actions. They were usable as is, however I had to have both of them smoothed up with the trigger pulls reduced to satisfy my levergun shooting soul. I can do pretty good work with heavy trigger pulls, however it takes a lot more concentration. The Henry .357 Magnum was ready to go right out of the box.
The main emphasis here has been on traditional leverguns for the simple reason that is where my heart is. However, others of note have also been offered in the past. Perhaps, most shooters feel as I do as these versions did not last very long. Marlin offered their Levermatic Lever action with a concealed hammer and chambered in .256 Winchester, .22 Jet, and .30 Carbine. Ruger also offered the same style lever action chambered in .44 Magnum. Earlier Ruger tried to go modern with their semi-automatic .44 Magnum Deerstalker Carbine which was and is a very handy carbine especially for hunting in brush and deep timber for such as deer, black bear, and most assuredly feral hogs. There was also a second version, the Deerfield, offered for a short time, however this one is also out of production.
I recently took stock of what PCCs lever-action style I have had extensive experience with and came up with the following chamberings in Marlin, Winchester, Browning, Rossi, Uberti and El Tigre leverguns. In order from smallest to largest those are .32 Magnum, .32-20, .327 Magnum, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, .38-40, .41 Magnum, .44-40, .44 Special, .44 Magnum, and .45 Colt. I was even able to fire the original .454 chambered Winchester 1894 as well as a comparable Marlin. Both actions proved to be inadequate to handle the high pressures of the .454, however Rossi did make it work. None of these .454s can be called pleasant to shoot. Bighorn Armory now offers their lever action in both .500 S&W, not really a pistol-length cartridge, and .475 Linebaugh, however at this stage of my life though I might really like to experience them this is a case where the spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak.
My favorite rifles are leverguns, and my favorite leverguns are the Trappers, that is those with barrel lengths of 16-1/4”. Before government in its infinite wisdom made shorter lengths illegal factories offered barrel lengths such as 12” and 14” which would certainly be exceptionally handy. My all around Perfect Rifle is a PCC levergun chambered in .357 Magnum and outfitted as the above-mentioned stainless steel Rossi. Properly loaded it also makes a very effective home defense rifle. Especially in such a situation I appreciate the fact I’m in control of loading the next cartridge into the chamber. There is nothing I am likely to encounter in my area that cannot be handled with a .357 levergun such as this, and if I ever wander into a more challenging environment I can always reach for a Trapper in .44 Magnum or set up for Heavy .45 Colt.