The need for a 44 Magnum?
by Art 
, Littleton, Colorado, Wednesday, May 06, 2015, 16:20 (3493 days ago)
I am starting to think I may not need a 44 Mag revolver. I have a 44 Special Ruger Flat Top that will do almost any thing I want a revolver to do. That along with a large frame Ruger 45 Colt, a 357 S&W 686 and a 41 Magnum Freedom Arms. I can hand load the 45 Colt to equal the 44 Mag. Also, lately I have been down loading more and more the 44 Mag. I used to load 10 Grains of Unique and a 240 Grain hard cast for many years for a every day load but as I age my artheritic hands do not care fo it much. Ireally wonder if I will use it much any more.
might be hard to justify, but you do need it
by bj , Wednesday, May 06, 2015, 20:09 (3493 days ago) @ Art
Any hard core shooter NEEDS one, or more.
I used to think that the advantages of the .44mag were the variety of very good gun models that it was available in, and the wide selection of factory ammunition that is available for it.
Yes you can load the Ruger .45Colt to equal or exceed it, so in that regards you could do without the .44mag. For that matter the .41mag is pretty close to the .44mag.
In reality if you handload the .45Colt could replace all of the guns you listed, but that doesn't mean you don't need any of the others.
try 185grJHP/1800fps below SAAMI max in .45....nt
Nt
try 185grJHP/1800fps below SAAMI max in .45....nt
by Art , Littleton, Colorado, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 06:47 (3493 days ago) @ passing by
Never considered such a load in the old Colt. WOW!!!!!!!!!
To each their own, but.....
I hold the opinion that the 44 Mag is the basic handgun. Turn the thing around and look at it from the other end.
The 44 Mag will do anything the 44 Special can do and more.
The 44 Mag will do anything the 41 Mag will do and more.
The 44 Mag will do anything the 357 Mag will do and more.
The 44 Mag will do anything the 45 Colt will do and more unless you are using "Ruger only" loads.
So the questions isn't, do I need a 44 Mag, when I have all these other guns. The question is, do I need all these other guns when I have a 44 Mag.
I own many handguns of various calibers, but I am not getting rid of my 44 Mags. They would be the last ones to go as with them I can cover what any of the others can do.
You guys keep trying to put "NEED" into the equation
and the retail gun business will collapse under it's own weight in a year.
I closed a lot of gun sales with the phrase "You're needs and your wants are two differnt things. You can live with out your needs for a while".
Charles, as in most things, 'cept cats & John Wayne is Right
by Rob Leahy 
, Prescott, Arizona, Friday, May 08, 2015, 11:08 (3491 days ago) @ Charles
on the money. Load it up or down carry it for defense ot hunting shooting competition, like Bowling Pins, ICORE , Informal, local combat matches, plink, punch nice round holes into small clusters, etc.
--
Of the Troops & For the Troops
The need for a 44 Magnum? You need one to know
by Hobie , Shenandoah Valley of Virginia, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 09:08 (3493 days ago) @ Art
edited by Hobie, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 09:14
why you don't.
I got a .44 Mag early on (a 629-1 4"). I find that the normal load in .45 Colt or .44 Special or .41 Mag Police load is really all I need. I do have the Redhawk to handle the 300 gr. loaded out. Hell for stout that and more than these others and I would carry every day if I lived with Mr. Grizzly. I don't.
PS - of course you might find out that you need the .44 Mag and not anything else. It is still your call, at least for a while yet.
--
Sincerely,
Hobie
Well, to fill a gaping hole in the line-up!
by Hoot , Diversityville, Liberal-sota, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 09:30 (3493 days ago) @ Art
Sheesh. Act as if there were nothing between .41 and .45.....
Happy Birthday?
by Rob Leahy , Prescott, Arizona, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 12:00 (3492 days ago) @ Art
I couldn't imagine being without a .44 mag!
--
Of the Troops & For the Troops
Happy Birthday?
by Art , Littleton, Colorado, Thursday, May 07, 2015, 19:38 (3492 days ago) @ Rob Leahy
No. Just thinking. Almost always gets me in trouble. But thank you.
Art